When dealing with interim order extensions, it is always helpful to have a recent example to hand where the regulator’s application was soundly rejected. Moreover, the court used the opportunity to make some pointed observations about the approach which should be taken to interim orders.
In applying for an extension of the interim order, the NMC was required to produce a witness statement setting out the history of the case and why the statutory test was met. In this instance, the court considered this statement was seriously deficient. The judge reminded regulators:
“The regulator’s evidence must be candid and complete. It should never depend on the professional being present or represented and filling in gaps or correcting a false impression. The onus of proof is on the regulator… The key points, both for and against an extension of time, should be succinctly put in the body of a witness statement, with an indexed and paginated exhibit in support. Most cases will require a cross referenced chronology”
The case had an extensive history of delays. The court observed that the conduct of the regulator may well be relevant to its assessment of risk:
“If the regulator by its delays, lack of urgency, lack of rigour, or in any other way signals that the matter is not receiving appropriate resources and attention, the court may take that into account. Failure to progress a case may indicate a lack of focus and urgency which, in the absence of a compelling explanation, might undermine the credibility of the application for an extension.”
The court also issued a salutary reminder concerning the length of interim orders:
“An interim order should not usually last for more than a year or two, counting the whole of the time from its beginning (when imposed by a panel) to the end of the period of the extension sought from the court… A year or two should be regarded as a long time for the whole currency of an interim order, and not as a starting point to be routinely prolonged by multiple extensions. If progress is made within the primary timescales envisaged by Article 31, it will not be necessary to apply to the High Court at all.”
Finally, the court looked at the conditions in question. The panel had previously imposed conditions requiring – inter alia – that the registrant keep the NMC informed where they were working or studying. The court noted these conditions “do not seem to have anything to do with the protection of the public but seem to be designed to keep the NMC informed”. In other words, they were not “necessary” – as per the observations in Persand. It may be a helpful reminder for tribunals who impose notification requirements as standard for no reason.